|  CHICAGO JOURNAL
  One hundred 
              years of Mandel music  The cheerleaders greeted new arrivals with admirable 
              good humor, given that they were stationed, in perky maroon skirts 
              and tanks, just inside the open Reynolds Club entrance on a crisp 
              October night. The coeds held the door not only for their patrons, 
              former Maroons headed to a homecoming dinner celebrating the University’s 
              new Athletics Hall of Fame, but also for those who maneuvered past 
              a second formation of cheerleaders and a clutch of jolly guests, 
              seeking Reynolds’s more sedate recesses—the season’s 
              opening-night concert at Mandel Hall. 
               
                |  Photo by Dan Dry |   
                | Mandel Hall patrons settle in for 
                  opening night. |  Not to be outdone by the hall-of-famers, Mandel’s 
              foyer also featured student greeters (in black slacks and white 
              shirts) waiting for the crowds. The greeters, explained fourth-year 
              house manager Andrew Elliott-Chandler, “really just smile 
              at people, help them to their seats. A lot of our subscribers have 
              been coming here for 20 or 30 years—and they like to make 
              small talk and tell the usher that they’ve been coming here 
              for 20 or 30 years.”  As scattered, discreet decorations proclaimed, 
              Mandel Hall has hosted music lovers for 100 years as of this fall. 
              A gift from department-store tycoon Leon Mandel, the auditorium 
              is modeled after the great hall of Crosby House, built in 1472 by 
              the sheriff of London and rented to Richard III after his nephews 
              were imprisoned in the Tower. At the 1903 opening ceremony, Harry 
              Pratt Judson, then dean of the faculties of arts, literature, and 
              science, said, “The dream of the builder is frozen into marble, 
              is petrified for the ages in gray stone and oaken carvings; his 
              floating fantastic visions are caught and embalmed in gargoyle and 
              in chiseled dragon.”  But where Judson saw a “poem in stone and 
              oak,” a more recent observer was assaulted by a “Gothic 
              monstrosity,” as longtime ticket-holder Ann Marks called the 
              hall before the evening’s performance. Even the “ornate 
              balcony, detailed oak woodwork, ornamental painting, and majestic 
              windows” boasted of in the concert notes were yet more blemishes 
              on “one of the ugliest buildings” she’d ever seen. 
              But once the lights went down, all was forgiven. Marks comes to 
              “as many [concerts] as they give,” she said, because 
              “the music is great and gets better every year.” Indeed, 
              Mandel has featured the Chicago debuts of violinist Isaac Stern 
              and guitarist Andrea Sergovia, and, more recently, violinist Hilary 
              Hahn and soprano Cecilia Bartoli. Tonight’s performance, produced 
              by the University of Chicago Presents, featured the widely praised 
              Emerson Quartet playing Beethoven’s Quartet No. 15 in A Minor, 
              with special guests and University artists-in-residence Pacifica 
              Quartet joining them for Mendelssohn’s Octet in E-flat Major. While the musicians were still hidden inside 
              the empty hall, finishing rehearsals, the foyer was occupied by 
              the dozen or so fans who arrived an hour early, hoping to secure 
              last-minute seats for the nearly sold-out show. Jonathan, a young 
              North Sider, heard that the Emerson Quartet was coming to town and 
              found Mandel through Google. College student Lena came thinking 
              student tickets were free. (Her date, fellow College student Gabriel, 
              had earlier purchased tickets from the box office—$15 with 
              valid student ID, $35 otherwise.) As the crowd swelled and the hum of conversation 
              (“I just can’t keep my ears off of that Mendelssohn”) 
              competed with the laughter of former athletes enjoying predinner 
              cocktails, the musicians relinquished the stage while the 12 greeters-cum-ushers 
              adjourned to their preshow pep talk in the hall’s hot and 
              cramped anteroom. When the doors finally opened 20 minutes late, 
              it became clear that not only the antechamber was unusually warm. 
              Concertgoers, finding their seats, fanned themselves vigorously 
              with their 100th-anniversary program notes, and in her introductory 
              remarks Marna Seltzer, director of University of Chicago Presents, 
              riffed about Mandel’s famously “warm” acoustic 
              tones. But once the crowd settled, the temperature cooled enough 
              to allow the Emerson Quartet the audience’s undivided attention. Of the evening’s first half, Chicago 
              Tribune music critic John von Rhein gushed in his Sunday column, 
              “With a breadth of vision equal to that of the music itself, 
              the [Emerson Quartet] balanced inwardness with extroversion, poetry 
              with passion. … The result was Beethoven playing of the very 
              highest order.” After extended curtain calls the temperature 
              rose again as the crowd meandered toward the exits for fresh air 
              or cigarettes. Some patrons praised the performance (“You 
              can never lose with Beethoven”), but the loudest voices wondered 
              about the night’s Cubs-Marlins playoff game. Conflicting reports 
              circulated: it was the bottom of the eighth; the top of the fifth; 
              Cubs up 4–2; Cubs down by 1. The hall-of-famers, who might 
              have commiserated with the sports-deprived ticketholders, were busy 
              with a dinner presentation. When the lights flickered, the concertgoers filed 
              back to their seats and found the Pacifica Quartet poised opposite 
              the Emerson Quartet, ready to perform the second piece. A shorter 
              work, the Mendelssohn was played with “sheer energy and freshness,” 
              von Rhein wrote, as “the eight musicians meshed with a precision 
              and finesse.”  After another exhaustive round of bravos and 
              curtain calls, many patrons retreated to the C-shop for complimentary 
              dessert and a chance to chat with the musicians, who threaded their 
              way through the crowd carrying their instruments on their backs 
              like traveling minstrels. While the concertgoers munched on brownies 
              and hummed snippets of Beethoven, the Cubs all but forgotten, a 
              contingent of hall-of-famers, their evening ceremony over, beelined 
              to Jimmy’s to catch the final innings.—A.L.M. 
   
 |  |