Out of the ring, into the
Illustration by Richard Thompson
A Frenchman who learned to box at the Woodlawn
Boys Club, Loic Wacquant, AM’86, PhD’94, also spars
in academic circles.
Loic Wacquant’s doctorates—from Chicago
and from l’École des hautes études en sciences
sociales in Paris—are in sociology. But when Wacquant, AM’86,
PhD’94, visited campus in early May, he came as the guest
of the anthropology department, talking about a new form of ethnography
as practiced in his long-awaited book, Body and Soul: Notebooks
of an Apprentice Boxer (Oxford University Press, 2004).
Never mind that anthropologists, worried about
issues of subjectivity, are reevaluating the ethnographic enterprise.
The 43-year-old Wacquant (pronounced Vah-KAHN) believes in the value
of what he calls “carnal sociology” or “ethnography
by conversion.” His ideal of experimental ethnography, of
entering into the situation body and soul, is “not going native
in a naive way,” he told an anthropology workshop, “but
carrying in your backpack all the tools you have from your discipline.”
There is, of course, a risk. As he found out, you might drop your
After planning to write his dissertation on colonialism
in New Caledonia, the French-controlled Pacific island where he’d
fulfilled his military service, Wacquant found his interest shifting
to the American ghetto. In August 1988 a friend mentioned a boxing
gym a few blocks from Wacquant’s graduate-student housing
on the edge of the Woodlawn neighborhood, and he saw a visit there
as a way to gain some introductions.
But when he entered the sweat- and liniment-soaked
arena of the Woodlawn Boys Club, presided over by DeeDee Armour,
a national legend among boxing coaches, Wacquant—a 5-foot,
8-inch, white welterweight from a small village in southern France—needed
to explain his presence in the 63rd Street gym: “I couldn’t
say, ‘I’m here to find an entrée into the ghetto.
Could I sit on the side and take notes?’ So I said the only
thing I could say: ‘I want to learn to box.’”
With that Wacquant, who’d played soccer
and tennis as a youth but knew nothing about boxing, began to train.
“What I had not anticipated was that I would get drawn into
that world,” he says, so much so that soon “I was not
coming to campus.” The academic arena seemed “dead,”
despite the fact that he was a promising student with two influential
mentors—the French social theorist Pierre Bourdieu and Harvard
sociologist William Julius Wilson, then teaching at Chicago and
his dissertation adviser.
Life was in the gym. He spent hours there each
day, month after month, eventually fighting (and narrowly losing)
a 1990 Chicago Golden Gloves bout. Granted a three-year appointment
to Harvard University’s Society of Fellows, he stayed on in
Chicago until Harvard recalled him to Cambridge in 1991. The gym
closed in 1992, and eventually the building was razed, his pugilistic
paradise paved into a parking lot.
All that was left was to turn the notes he’d
never stopped taking into a book. At a 57th Street Books author
event, Wacquant joked about the decade his friends from the gym
had to wait for autographed copies of Body and Soul (first
published in 2001 as Corps & âme, Carnets ethnographiques
d’un apprenti boxeur). Armour, to whom the book is dedicated,
never got his copy; he died in February 2000, and the 57th Street
appearance was Wacquant’s memorial to his coach.
The book was hard going. Leaving the gym around
which he had come to shape his daily life created “a deep
abyss of depression.” Advance reports meant that “I’d
become sort of a circus animal,” pointed out at conferences
as “the boxing sociologist”—a celebrity that seemed
to raise false expectations for the work. And, he admits, “I
didn’t know what form to give it,” an indecision that
reflected his dissatisfaction with the ethnographic genre.
After his Harvard fellowship ended in 1993 he
joined the sociology faculty at the University of California, Berkeley.
Over the next decade—dividing time between Berkeley, a research
appointment at the Centre de sociologie européenne du Collège
de France, and visiting professorships in the United States and
abroad—he earned a 1997 MacArthur “genius” fellowship,
cofounded the journal Ethnography (2000), and published
some 100 articles on sociology, anthropology, criminology, social
theory, social policy, philosophy, and urban and cultural studies.
He also found a way to write Body and Soul.
The book begins, he explains, with a “sociological
scaffolding,” an analysis of boxing’s role in the ghetto:
dissecting the sport as craft and vocation in an environment where
other forms of employment or order are unavailable. Next comes the
ethnography, what he terms “fine-grained description of a
particular population in a particular place and time.” Edited
field notes, portraits of individual boxers, and “carefully
placed” photographs also play roles in his attempt to stay
“close to the ground to probe the inner lives of boxers and
disclose the sensual, moral, and aesthetic pull of their craft.”
If Wacquant is somewhat happy with Body and
Soul, he is less sanguine about the state of urban sociology.
He said so with typical bluntness in a May 2002 American Journal
of Sociology review of three major urban-poverty studies—Code
of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner
City, by Elijah Anderson, AM’72, who teaches at Penn;
Sidewalk, by Mitchell D. Duneier, AM’85, PhD’92,
now at Princeton, and No Shame in My Game: The Working Poor
in the Inner City, by Harvard’s Katherine Newman.
All three books, Wacquant argued, followed the
“unwritten ‘code of writing about the (black) poor’
in U.S. sociology,” misreading the ethnographic evidence to
“bring good news and leave the reader feeling reassured that
individual- and local-level remedies are ready at hand.” Anderson,
Duneier, and Newman fought back, taking issue with both his micro-
and macroanalyses of their works—and pointing out that, in
Newman’s words, “Wacquant’s credentials as an
ethnographer have yet to be tested in the world of English-language
His credentials, though, are building. Body and
Soul will be followed in July by Deadly Symbiosis: Race and
the Rise of Neoliberal Penality (Polity Press). It too is an
interdisciplinary marriage of genres, “mating,” as Wacquant
writes, “ethnography (a ground-level portrait of L.A. County
Jail), social history (a recapitulation of racial domination in
the U.S. from the initial days of slavery), and theory (it puts
forth a set of principles to escape the ‘crime-and-punishment’
paradigm that continues to dominate research on the prison).”
Continuing to blend fieldwork and theory, he
is at work on a second boxing book; The Passion of the Pugilist,
he says, is a “theoretically driven” study of “the
social constitution of desire and its role in domination and exploitation.”
His “next big project,” Peculiar Institutions,
is “a comparative historical sociology of the forms and mechanisms
of racial domination.”
This spring Wacquant moved to the New School
University as distinguished university professor in sociology, prompted
by “getting closer to Europe, trying out New York City life,
and better research support.” Though there’s “no
time to go to the gym,” he’s found a bit of the Woodlawn
Boys Club in his Tribeca apartment building: “There’s
a hard bag, and I go beat it every day.”—M.R.Y.