Arsenic
and Old Bronze
The work of
Aslihan Yener, above left, proves that the APS is not only for the
biological and physical sciences. This past spring, the Oriental
Institute associate professor used a bending magnet beamline at
the Synchrotron Radiation Instrumentation CAT—whose goals include
attracting new research communities to synchrotron radiation—to
scan an ancient tin-bronze figurine. Although Yener’s scan was one
of the first times synchrotron radiation had been used on an archaeological
object, it’s possible that the technique may be the biggest boon
to archaeology since the introduction of radiocarbon dating.
Made in about
3,000 B.C. in southern Turkey’s Amuq Valley and excavated by Oriental
Institute archaeologists in the 1930s, the 11-inch statuette is
among the oldest known figures made from tin bronze, a copper-tin
alloy. The figure’s chemical composition was characterized by spectroscopic
methods in 1949, but the APS X-ray fluorescence study still revealed
surprises.
For one, the
scan showed that the figurine had been broken near the knee and
repaired with a lower-melting bronze that contains arsenic. The
repair was barely perceptible to the naked eye. Its quality, as
well as the choice of soldering material, Yener says, indicated
a higher level of technical skill in the artisans than the archaeologists
had expected.
“What the
APS promises to do is give us much more controlled and sensitive
analyses,” says Yener. “It can also, theoretically, give us a CAT
scan–like image—that is, we will be able to look into the inner
macro- and microstructure of the figurine without damaging it. You
don’t have to damage it, you don’t have to chop off a part of it,
in order to understand how it’s made.”
In November,
Yener and colleagues from the Synchrotron Radiation Instrumentation
CAT and the Field Museum began a series of tomographic analyses,
looking at the interior structure of the figurine, a samurai sword
in the Field’s collection, and other artifacts. As Yener says, the
process is similar to a medical CAT scan, in which horizontal X-rays
are taken of a person’s body, with the resulting series of scans
used to reconstruct a three-dimensional picture of the interior.
“These types
of techniques are very well developed for soft tissue and fossils,”
Yener notes, “but materials such as metals are a different story
altogether. It will be quite difficult, I’m told, but it is certainly
worth pushing the envelope.”
The challenge
comes from the extremely high energies needed to penetrate the metal
and see inside. A typical X-ray can’t penetrate more than 20 microns
into a metal object. But beams from the APS can penetrate much further,
and should not do any damage to the artifact.
Just in case,
the researchers will start by experimenting with dummy samples.
Not only are the actual artifacts valuable enough to require a guard
at the beamline, they are also delicate. With the dummies, researchers
can relax while they fine-tune the measurement method, performing
dry runs to prepare for the real thing.
“What the
tomographic image will allow us to do,” explains Yener, “is to understand
the manufacturing history of the figurine. Was it cast? Was it hammered?
What temperature was it worked at? Was it coated with some other
metals?
“We’d like
to be able to define technological styles—that is, how things were
made in particular areas and particular times. Embedded in the technology
is a set of cultural choices that were made in order to make a particular
tool or artifact.” Knowing about such choices will, she says, “add
another dimension to our understanding of these ancient cultures.”
Yener is also
using the X-ray fluorescence technology at APS to study the chemical
composition of layers of sediment that accumulated over thousands
of years. Drilled from the bed of a relic lake in the Amuq Valley
that was drained in the 1950s and ’60s, the deepest and oldest layers
of the sediment core have been dated to the end of the last ice
age. Changes in the composition over time, Yener explains, tell
the stories of erosion, pollution, changes in irrigation and hydrology,
and the advent of mining and smelting in the region.
“We’re able
to reconstruct the environment of that valley over time,” she says.
“It covers the period of the development of human civilization in
the region.”
A side benefit
to the collaboration these projects require, Yener notes, is that
“the scientists we work with come at this problem from an entirely
different point of view. They contribute a great deal of insight
and ask questions that we in the archaeological community may not
have thought of.” She and scientists from the U of C, Argonne, the
Field Museum, and the University of Illinois hope to develop a National
Science Foundation Science and Technology Center at Argonne. Devoted
to the study of ancient technology and environment, the center would
have access to an APS sector. The group’s pre-proposal passed the
initial NSF review in May; the group is now submitting a full proposal,
with a funding decision to be made by next summer.—D.S.
|