Chicago
Journal
Doing business vicariously
After winning the University’s
New Venture Challenge, a GSB student launches his plan to connect
small businesses with marketers.
Photo by Dan Dry |
Moyer's
sunny start-up offices are in the Chicago Sun-Times building. |
In contrast to the dark, industrial-gray
hallways of the Chicago Sun-Times building and the bustling activity
of the neighboring FOX News offices, Vicarious Communications is
a sunny mix of red, blue, and yellow walls. Only three full-time
staff are camped on the edge of an expanse of unoccupied cubicles.
It’s pretty quiet, but while CEO and Graduate School of Business
(GSB) evening student Michael Moyer concedes that business might
not be “booming,” he hopes that his start-up will get
started soon.
The 32-year-old Moyer has reason
to be hopeful: he won $25,000 in this year’s New Venture Challenge
(NVC), an annual GSB business-plan competition. Moyer’s brainchild
is a marketing system to allow small businesses such as hair salons
and orthodontists to increase sales without violating ethical and
governmental regulations against releasing customer information
to manufacturers. Lacking time and training, an orthodontist, for
example, is less equipped to sell any particular product—say,
cinnamon-flavored braces—to a target customer—perhaps
a young woman who thinks her teeth are crooked and likes cinnamon—than
is the manufacturer. But without customer data, the manufacturer
can’t identify targets as well as the orthodontist.
Vicarious Communications, Moyer
says, will bridge that gap, providing software that lets the orthodontist
browse available advertising campaigns, identify target customers,
and send marketing materials—without sharing customer information
with the manufacturer. Because businesses will send client information
only to Moyer’s company, and not a host of manufacturers,
those businesses regulated by the Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act (HIPAA), such as orthodontists, must obtain only
one customer-release form.
Though Moyer, with a master’s
degree in integrated-marketing communications from Northwestern,
began developing his marketing software concept five years ago,
he created a similar—though low-tech— company in 1990,
as an undergraduate at the University of Kansas. With a six- to
eight-person staff, Banana Graphics ran programs for businesses
including Nantucket’s Bamboo Lounge, trading hats and T-shirts
for customer names and addresses, which were then added to catalog
mailing lists. “It worked really well,” Moyer says,
“but we didn’t have computers back then. We were keeping
our database on index cards.”
Vicarious Communications, on the
other hand, only became possible after small businesses embraced
the Internet. But before Moyer could get online, he had to get his
idea out of the ether and onto paper, a process that began more
than a year ago with the launch of the 2003 NVC. Part of the GSB’s
Polsky Center for Entrepreneurship, the seven-year-old contest,
sponsored by Zebra Technologies’ Edward Kaplan, MBA’71,
is an annual business-plan competition that awards seed money to
the most promising prospective start-up. To form his team, Moyer
recruited fellow GSB student Alyson Tesler and a non-GSB former
colleague from HyperFeed Technologies, Adam Schuler.
The first step was preparing an
executive summary—a brief description of the business’s
market, strategies, and objectives—to compete for a spot in
a spring-quarter seminar class taught by clinical professor of entrepreneurship
Ellen Rudnick, who heads the Polsky Center. Once in, Moyer and the
other teams’ GSB members presented their ideas to venture
capitalists, refined them according to the (sometimes harsh) criticism
they received, and presented them again until they completed the
course with a polished plan.
In the final phase, eight of the 25 original teams gave formal presentations
at the Gleacher Center, where Vicarious Communications beat out
second-place-winners Green Hedges (insurance-industry financial
services) and Iterative Therapeutics (antibody-therapy development),
both of which received $12,500.
Winning the NVC, Moyer says, means
“I’ve gotten to the point where I have an investment.
Back then it was an idea and a PowerPoint presentation.” Vicarious
Communications, which begins with the veterinary industry this fall
and expands to dentistry next year, is ready to launch the software,
which will bring in revenue, but still needs funding for further
development.
“This is definitely an angel
company,” Moyer says, meaning that wealthy individuals, or
“angel investors” (as opposed to large venture-capital
firms), will most likely provide the capital needed to expand. And
that’s the sticking point—though he’s been frugal
with the prize money, using it to fund market research and software
development, raising additional capital is more difficult than he
imagined. “Everyone says, ‘Oh, it’s hard to raise
money.’ If you really want to learn how hard it is to raise
money, I can tell you, because I’ve been in it.” But
the present lack of funding doesn’t stop Moyer from thinking
ahead. With software that can be tailored to any number of small
businesses, he says, “three, four years down the road, I see
us becoming experts in this process in different industries so we
have hair salons and ophthalmologists and chiropractors and dermatologists...”
Of past NVC contestants, 25 have
gone on to become viable companies. Of those, nine have merged or
been sold, including Flyswat. Designed by John Rodkin, a current
GSB and Law School student, and Ray Krouse, MBA’99, the Web-browsing
program was bought by NBCi three years ago for $100 million. That’s
the kind of precedent Moyer hopes to follow.—A.L.M.
|
|